GUILD News Flash | Bringing recognition to the Project Controls Profession

Critical activities more than non-critical

4 replies [Last post]
SM PUM
User offline. Last seen 22 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 15 Nov 2011
Points: 76

Hi planners

I have submitted a schedule to my manager and he has returned it with following comments;

Critical Activities are more than non Critical Activities. Try to minimize these critical activities.

 

Please Advice

Replies

Hi Hall

If you have a programme that has a start point and a clear cascade of tasks to an end point then there will be only one critical path.

If there is more than one CP then the chances of this occurring naturally are infinitesimal - therefore the most likely answer is the programme has been rigged.

You can of course have a number of such sectional cascades in a single programme.

Best regards

Mike Testro

Christopher Hall
User offline. Last seen 36 weeks 4 days ago. Offline
Joined: 17 May 2012
Points: 43
Groups: GPC Australia

Mike,

Good run thought.  Concurrent critical paths are, in circumstances, justifiable thou.

SM also check to see if you haven’t inadvertently imposed a project must finish by constraint earlier than planned/ forecast.

Chris

Hi SM

You can start by removing all constraints that force criticality.

Next check how many tasks are set ALAP - they show critical even when there have lots of float.

After that look at what critical tasks remain and if more that 50% look to find out why -

First review any tasks more that 20 days long

Next check tasks with more than 1 outgoing link - are they all necessary?

Finally there an only be one critical path - if you have more than 1 youre programme has been rigged.

Best regards

Mike Testro

Christopher Hall
User offline. Last seen 36 weeks 4 days ago. Offline
Joined: 17 May 2012
Points: 43
Groups: GPC Australia

SM,

Your manager may be refering to the quantity of critical activities.  I.e. 3/4 of the programme may be critical, 1/4 non critical.

Depending upon your stance on such a broad brush approach to a programme review, the statement may be justified.

Chris

Market Place

A comprehensive product suite with the flexibility to meet the varying needs of everyone involved in running projects
EVA18 is the major UK event for Project Control knowledge, know-how and networking. EVA is a conference organised by a project management practitioner for project practitioners and stakeholders
We want to build software that solves real problems, allow people to work more productive and happier.
The book is designed for users of earlier versions to upgrade their skills and for new planners to learn the software.
A user guide and training manual written for professionals who wish to learn how to plan and control projects in an established Primavera Enterprise environment with or without Resources & Roles.