Dear Arend,

when you need to accelerate the work (crash your schedule) and select different options one of them is to afford overtime. Playing what if scenarios you will want to understand what you will get and how much it will cost. People do not work overtime without a permission and if it happens then it was planned.

I think that Pro's will be happy to model all possible options and select the best solution taking into account not only time but also money. It is not the best practice to calculate actual expenses that were not planned.

Best Regards,

Vladimir

Edwin,

there was a special discussion http://www.planningplanet.com/forums/primavera-version-pm5-pm6/519905/overtime-input-primavera-p6 and I did not find the satisfactory answer there.

I don't know the answer myself and can only explain how overtime rates are modelled and calculated in Spider Project.

I suggest to start new discussion on this topic with the theme that sounds like "P6 is not the right tool for project budgeting. It cannot plan even so simple items as overtime costs!"

With this statement you will attract an attention of many P6 distributors that attend this forum and I hope that some of them will propose some reasonable solution.

Best luck,

Vladimir

It is not uncommon to require in the same activity for some resource assignments to be fixed units/time while others to be fixed duration & units. In this case fixing the assignment rules all at the activity level instead of at both, the activity level and the team level, will prevent correct modeling.

Take a look at the following assignment.

For activity 1

• resource A must work on the activity 50 hours when available and can work independently of other resources,
• resource B must work on the activity 30 hours when available and can work independently of other resources
• and resources, A and B must work together when available, in this case it came out to be for 30 hours each at 50% workload or 4 hours/day or 30/4 = 7.5 days.

Of course the assignment can be allowed to be of variable workload per day to be determined on availability which will complicate the assignment further making it very difficult to to allocate by hand.

It is important to be able to distinguish the individual assignments for transparency, for understanding and in order to make sure it works as intended otherwise the software can be making unintended allocations and you not figuring it out so easily.

Hi,

I use both MS Projects and Primavera for planning but for resource planning i tend to use only the MS projects. my Main Is to estimate the Manpower for the project. My project is a Very Large scale project having manpower around 5000 Nos.

I have a problem is assigning resource for this large scale on primavera, for eg: i need to assign a resource for a Footing work - i require 10 Masons and 5 Barbenders and 3 Carpenters for that job. But in primavera i am not able to assign in terms of numbers. For multiple activities in MS project if i am going to assign the resources it would provide a total no of labours required. But this case is Not possible in Primavera. I have attached a Sheet showing the resources in MS Projects. Kindly Let me know if it is possible in Primavera

msp_file.jpg

In this case you get to assign two kinds of engineers like civil and mechanical ,, civil work 4hrs /day nd mechanical 8hrs / day... Please, let me know if u need any more info..

Thank you,

HANSON

Sir,

Default Units/Time = number of Hours every single resources will work during specific time like 8Hr/Day..

and Max Units/Time= number of units X default units/time = (5 engineers working per day and every one working 8 hrs)= 5x8 =40...

So, you have only two to change the default units/time and the Max units/time..

Please, let me know if you need any more info..

Thank you,

HANSON