Push to move away from WBS to Activity Codes

Hii,

Anyone gettibng pressure from Company to move away from WBS to using solely Activity Codes?

I know primavera/oracle have been pushing this but don't know how far this has gone.

Usually non-planners push this type of change.

D
Dennis Hanks 👤 Member for 19 years 2 months

[Stepping on my soap box]

For me, the value lies in linking the schedule to the estimate/budget.  If your estimate/budget is not organized by project WBS, there is little additional value over activity codes - except that P6 seems to really like using a WBS.

No suggestion that any schedule not be fully integrated - resource loaded - with Estimating and Accounting.  In other words, IMHO, all schedules should be resource loaded and therefore rely on a fully developed WBS - use activity codes whenever the need arises.  It is not an either/or, but rather what is appropriate.  

All schedules should be resource loaded from a source external to the planner/scheduler and this source be cited in the Schedule Basis.

[now stepping down from my soap box]

M
mimoune djouallah 👤 Member for 19 years 8 months

you can easily map your wbs to use activity code instead, just excel and the use of the sdk

S
Sam . 👤 Member for 16 years 10 months

No pressure at my end. Yet. Seems to be common practice to use WBS elements.

Forum Sponsor

Top Posters

James Williams
74 posts
Johannes Vandenberg
14 posts
Soheil Barekat
4 posts
Peter Holroyd
51 posts
Neil Atkinson
5 posts
Trian Asmoro
1 posts
Erkan Polater
9 posts
Luis Jr Ngade
6 posts
Ben Welsher
1 posts
Rohan Dashputre
0 posts