You should not import start and finish dates into your schedule this is what the program along with the durations, logic and calendar does for you. If you want to import start dates you have to import it as an activity with a primary constraint and the constraint date and you have to make sure the TIMES are included. If you want to import the finish date you can either import it as a secondary constraint or import an expected finish date.
You can import actual start and actual finish dates.
Importing dates in primavera p6 from spread sheet is always tricky and it is not 100% right as per my experience, However I have a solution for you if you are going to update your program by using previously updated program or vice versa.In this case I am only changing Actuals of program w.r.t otherone .Lets say you have 2 programs
Program 1 : This is the program ON which start dates are to be imported.
Program 2 : Whose dates are to be imported on program 1.
Its a bit tricky . Make program 2 baseline of Program 1 and apply gobal changes
where
BL1 activity %age is greater than 0%
change
actual date = BL1 start date
here In this case I am replacing only the updated dates from In-progress & completed activities of program 2 .
I am using Primavera P6 v7 for my project. I have a problem. I have imported activities from excel sheet, but finish date is not changed according to duration of activity.
i.e. Activity Start date + Duration= Finish Date
Finish date is not calculated automaticaly. how to set it to auto calculate like MS Project 2013.
Thanks for the explanation. Sorry, I don't doubt your expertise. And no, my solution won't work for Early Start. It's simply for maintaining the correct start dates when importing new activities, with start dates in the future, from a spreadsheet - which was what I was trying to do when I stumbled upon this forum. (I suppose it would work for dates in both past and future, if the Global Change criterion was changed to user-defined field <> Start Date)
Hopefully one of our answers is the one Ferdinand requires. Or even better, maybe he already resolved it months ago! My solution works for my situation but may not for his, depending on his circumstances. I was so pleased to find a solution, I just thought I'd share it.
Andy
Member for
20 years 3 months
Member for20 years3 months
Submitted by Hannes de Bruyne on Wed, 2011-11-30 10:09
Simple questions require simple answers. As Primavera works with CPM, also (Early) starts are calculated by links and durations. (Not by their own durations of course, but by the durations of their predecessors). During the planning phase, the data date is of no importance at all, so it does not have any infuence on Early Start, only during the monitoring and Control Phase this must be taken into account.
Although all your statements are correct, they might not be the right answer for this simple question. in all the years that I have been working with Primavera (and I started 20 years ago with Finest Hour) I met hundreds of planners, who did not know the very simple thing, that ES and EF are not entered but calculated by CPM rules. A lot of people still do not know the difference between Early start, Planned Start and Start dates - see discussions in the past. Therefore my simple answer could well be the answer to this question.
Ferdinand's problem is with Start dates, not Finish dates. Finish dates are calculated, as you say, by duration (and affected by the calendar being used). They always import OK, or close enough to adjust afterwards, if you include durations in the import spreadsheet.
The problem is that imported Start dates always default to the data date. This is fixed and unchangeable, so a work-around is needed, such as the one I posted yesterday, using user-defined date fields and a Global Change (which is not my own idea, incidentally - I got it from another forum! I only found this thread because I had exactly the same problem as Ferdinand and was looking online for a solution). This one truly works. It just takes a bit of setting up first.
I hope this clears things up.
All the best
Andy
Member for
20 years 3 months
Member for20 years3 months
Submitted by Hannes de Bruyne on Tue, 2011-11-29 14:40
this is absolutly right. Maybe you did not quit understand start and finish dates in Primavera. These dates are not entered (or imported), they are only calculated. Calculated on the basis of links and durations. E.g 3+4+5 =12 - if you export this calculation, reimport this with 13 instead of 12 you expect the result 3+4+5 = 13. This just wont work. You may import link details or new durations but never import dates. (only if these are constraint dates, which you should avoid to use as much as possible)
From what I can see here, the other people responding don't actually understand your original question. If you haven't already found the answer elsewhere, here is a method I have come across which works - at least for activities with start dates later than the data date.
In P6, you create user-defined start and finish date fields and add these columns into your project layout.
Export to Excel (the quickest way is using Edit – Select All, then right-click and Export to Excel) so these field headers appear in the spreadsheet.
Paste into this spreadsheet, under these headers, the data you wish to import into P6.
Copy the Start Date and Finish Date and paste them into the columns for the new user-defined fields.
When you import it into P6, the user-defined fields will have the correct dates.
In P6, under Tools, select Global Change and create a new one as follows:
If <user start date> is greater than DD (data date)
Then <Planned Start> = <user start date>
Run the change and the start date is corrected. Finish date automatically corrects according to the activity duration.
The user-defined finish date might appear redundant for this process but it is useful for comparing dates after the Global Change has been run, as different calendars will affect the finish date.
As adding the user fields and creating the Global Change are one-off activities, it’s now set up for future imports.
Cheers
Andy
Member for
19 years 6 months
Member for19 years6 months
Submitted by Joseph Erwin C… on Fri, 2011-02-18 21:18
The finish dates are calculated from the start date and the duration, make sure in the user preferences that you have the correct duration format selected (ie, if your xls durations are in days select days in P6). It will also be worth checking your project calendar as this needs to match, holidays, weekends etc ... Then import and schedule (F9) and you should have the correct dates.
Hope u followed my last instructions. As u said u r unable to see accurate dates in P6 after export from Excel.
After export from excel go in P6 > Clink on Edit > User Preferences > go on dates tab > there is date fomates chk any one what u like (u can see sample below) .
regards,,,,
Member for
18 years
Member for18 years
Submitted by Ferdinand Ancheta on Mon, 2011-02-14 01:34
At the outset Irfan, thanks for your reply. However, could you please clarify coz' i didn't understand well? To reiterate, i'm having problem importing the dates from excel and it didn't give me the correct dates in P6. Hence, my query is that if my dates in excel would be the culprit, if so, what would be the correct format of dates to export in P6?
After export ur data into excel > come in task Tab (in excel sheet) > come on column 'start_date '(*)Start > Inset a colum behind this column > copy all ur dated > use paste special in next column > & select add option from paste special.
Member for
16 years 4 monthsYou should not import start
You should not import start and finish dates into your schedule this is what the program along with the durations, logic and calendar does for you. If you want to import start dates you have to import it as an activity with a primary constraint and the constraint date and you have to make sure the TIMES are included. If you want to import the finish date you can either import it as a secondary constraint or import an expected finish date.
You can import actual start and actual finish dates.
Member for
8 years 10 monthsImporting dates in primavera
Importing dates in primavera p6 from spread sheet is always tricky and it is not 100% right as per my experience, However I have a solution for you if you are going to update your program by using previously updated program or vice versa.In this case I am only changing Actuals of program w.r.t otherone .Lets say you have 2 programs
Program 1 : This is the program ON which start dates are to be imported.
Program 2 : Whose dates are to be imported on program 1.
Its a bit tricky . Make program 2 baseline of Program 1 and apply gobal changes
where
BL1 activity %age is greater than 0%
change
actual date = BL1 start date
here In this case I am replacing only the updated dates from In-progress & completed activities of program 2 .
Hope you understand the concept .
Member for
11 years 8 monthsMember for
11 years 8 monthsI am using Primavera P6 v7
I am using Primavera P6 v7 for my project. I have a problem. I have imported activities from excel sheet, but finish date is not changed according to duration of activity.
i.e. Activity Start date + Duration= Finish Date
Finish date is not calculated automaticaly. how to set it to auto calculate like MS Project 2013.
[[wysiwyg_imageupload:2006:]]
Member for
13 years 11 monthsHannes Thanks for the
Hannes
Thanks for the explanation. Sorry, I don't doubt your expertise. And no, my solution won't work for Early Start. It's simply for maintaining the correct start dates when importing new activities, with start dates in the future, from a spreadsheet - which was what I was trying to do when I stumbled upon this forum. (I suppose it would work for dates in both past and future, if the Global Change criterion was changed to user-defined field <> Start Date)
Hopefully one of our answers is the one Ferdinand requires. Or even better, maybe he already resolved it months ago! My solution works for my situation but may not for his, depending on his circumstances. I was so pleased to find a solution, I just thought I'd share it.
Andy
Member for
20 years 3 monthsHello Andy Simple questions
Hello Andy
Simple questions require simple answers. As Primavera works with CPM, also (Early) starts are calculated by links and durations. (Not by their own durations of course, but by the durations of their predecessors). During the planning phase, the data date is of no importance at all, so it does not have any infuence on Early Start, only during the monitoring and Control Phase this must be taken into account.
Although all your statements are correct, they might not be the right answer for this simple question. in all the years that I have been working with Primavera (and I started 20 years ago with Finest Hour) I met hundreds of planners, who did not know the very simple thing, that ES and EF are not entered but calculated by CPM rules. A lot of people still do not know the difference between Early start, Planned Start and Start dates - see discussions in the past. Therefore my simple answer could well be the answer to this question.
Hannes
Member for
13 years 11 monthsHannes Ferdinand's problem is
Hannes
Ferdinand's problem is with Start dates, not Finish dates. Finish dates are calculated, as you say, by duration (and affected by the calendar being used). They always import OK, or close enough to adjust afterwards, if you include durations in the import spreadsheet.
The problem is that imported Start dates always default to the data date. This is fixed and unchangeable, so a work-around is needed, such as the one I posted yesterday, using user-defined date fields and a Global Change (which is not my own idea, incidentally - I got it from another forum! I only found this thread because I had exactly the same problem as Ferdinand and was looking online for a solution). This one truly works. It just takes a bit of setting up first.
I hope this clears things up.
All the best
Andy
Member for
20 years 3 monthsHello Ferdinand this is
Hello Ferdinand
this is absolutly right. Maybe you did not quit understand start and finish dates in Primavera. These dates are not entered (or imported), they are only calculated. Calculated on the basis of links and durations. E.g 3+4+5 =12 - if you export this calculation, reimport this with 13 instead of 12 you expect the result 3+4+5 = 13. This just wont work. You may import link details or new durations but never import dates. (only if these are constraint dates, which you should avoid to use as much as possible)
Hannes
Member for
13 years 11 monthsFerdinand From what I can see
Ferdinand
From what I can see here, the other people responding don't actually understand your original question. If you haven't already found the answer elsewhere, here is a method I have come across which works - at least for activities with start dates later than the data date.
The user-defined finish date might appear redundant for this process but it is useful for comparing dates after the Global Change has been run, as different calendars will affect the finish date.
As adding the user fields and creating the Global Change are one-off activities, it’s now set up for future imports.
Cheers
Andy
Member for
19 years 6 monthsGood day, Dear all, Please
Good day,
Dear all,
Please give me the link of discussion for the procedure om export and importing in P6, or you can give me in this thread.
thank you.
Joseph
Member for
19 years 2 monthsFerdinand The finish dates
Ferdinand
The finish dates are calculated from the start date and the duration, make sure in the user preferences that you have the correct duration format selected (ie, if your xls durations are in days select days in P6). It will also be worth checking your project calendar as this needs to match, holidays, weekends etc ... Then import and schedule (F9) and you should have the correct dates.
Andy
Member for
16 years 3 monthshi Ferdinand,
hi Ferdinand,
Hope u followed my last instructions. As u said u r unable to see accurate dates in P6 after export from Excel.
After export from excel go in P6 > Clink on Edit > User Preferences > go on dates tab > there is date fomates chk any one what u like (u can see sample below) .
regards,,,,
Member for
18 yearsAt the outset Irfan, thanks
At the outset Irfan, thanks for your reply. However, could you please clarify coz' i didn't understand well? To reiterate, i'm having problem importing the dates from excel and it didn't give me the correct dates in P6. Hence, my query is that if my dates in excel would be the culprit, if so, what would be the correct format of dates to export in P6?
Member for
16 years 3 monthsHi Ferdinand, After export ur
Hi Ferdinand,
After export ur data into excel > come in task Tab (in excel sheet) > come on column 'start_date '(*)Start > Inset a colum behind this column > copy all ur dated > use paste special in next column > & select add option from paste special.
i thinks it ill help u......
regards,,,,,,
Irfan Khan